« On visits and visitors ... Eric Peterson | Main | Google Analytics adds intergration with Google Checkout »

Oct14
Edelman's fake Walmart Blog

So, if you don't have a story, you fake one; you don't have a war, and your government is in power, you make one, no legit story - you make one up.  I'm told that's what Edelman did when ....

"......a blog ostensibly authored by a couple traveling across America in their RV and spending nights parked in WalMart parking lots turned out to be a fake blog, the brainchild of WalMart’s PR counselors at Edelman. While fake blogs (and other fake social media) are nothing new, it’s dismaying to see it emerge from Edelman, which has some of the smarter new-media people on its staff (Phil Gomes, Michael Wiley, Steve Rubel and more), and which touts itself as the PR firm that truly gets social media. This is the third time (as Todd Defren noted in his post) that Edelman has botched the whole social media thing on WalMart’s behalf. "

Sounds like laziness to me - or maybe there are no real people who'd travel around to WalMarts and park there (who are bloggers).  Having been caught ..... it might be hard for the PR firm to talk about it - if I were working at Edelman, I would not want to talk about it either.  MediaPost has the whole story.

"Although the bloggers were acknowledged only as Jim and Laura on the "Wal-Marting Across America" site, BusinessWeek identified one as Laura St. Claire, a freelance writer. Her partner, Jim, however, declined to provide his identity, "to protect his employer," the story says.

That protection lasted about 48 hours. In less than two days, the watchdog organization Wal-Mart Watch identified him as Jim Thresher, a 25-year employee of The Washington Post and a professional photographer.

One thing holds true, if people fake something in the blogosphere - and it's found out - your credibility is hot.

"Those smart PR folks working for Edelman are among the members of the PR community who advocate participation in the conversation. Some of them have been brutal when, to their way of thinking, somebody else fails to understand what it means to be engage in the conversation. So where is Edelman in this particular conversation? Missing in action. As dismaying as this latest misstep is, it’s even more dismaying to see Edelman’s high-powered social media experts failing to walk the talk. Nothing from Richard in his vaunted 6 a.m. blog. Nothing from Steve, who blogs at the pinnacle of PR’s A-list. Nothing from anybody (based on a Technorati search and a survey of the Edelman blogs). "

If someone wants to create a viral campaign and you can find bloggers who actually agree with the story (IE: want to go and blog about WalMart....that's OK in my book).  To create a conversation and a point of view that's fictitious - that's not OK.

 

related entries


6 Comments/Trackbacks




Do you suppose it's possible that the fake Wal-Mart blog WASN'T created by Edelman? After all, Wal-Mart is one huge gorilla that can do what it wants, including letting its agency be the fall guy for a bad internal decision. It just seems so incongruent for Edelman to create a fake campaign, especially knowing how Richard Edelman and Steve Rubel feel about such things. Worth considering, dontcha think?

You know, I'm GLAD that someone else is blogging about this.

(other than me, of course!)
http://www.deepjiveinterests.com/2006/10/14/edelman-gaming-blogosphere-with-walmart-again/

How is this NOT hitting the blogosphere, in the age of payperpost / reviewme / creamaid?

The ironic -- or hypocritical thing -- of course, is how Richard Edelman pontificated about 8 months ago how important it was to disclose this sort of thing.
http://www.edelman.com/speak_up/blog/archives/2006/03/a_word_to_the_w.html

... man, it is *rich*.

Shame on me for not blogging about this ... yet :). I recently reviewed Wal-Mart's corporate blogging efforts and was - well - quite dismayed. Tsk, tsk.

Good discussion here.

Dear Marshall,
Nice post thx for info.
According to
"Shame on me for not blogging about this ... yet :)"

Shame on me too :D

I'm going write about it on my site.

Regards

And would you expect anything less from walmart and there hired guns?Look how they treat there employees,Look at there hireing pratices,Hireing illeagle aliens to polish the floors at night,Low wages there employee can bearly live on,And you people support walmart by still shopping there?Now they hire people to lie to you to generate interest in there company,Now thats a Sad,Sad company.Piir employees,Walmart knows what best for them,the almighty profit and dollar,screw anyone else,why dont they make a blog about how walmart screws everyone????im sure no material will have to be made up about that.

submit a trackback

TrackBack URL for this entry:

post a comment

Name, Email Address, and URL are not required fields.





Comment Preview

« On visits and visitors ... Eric Peterson | Main | Google Analytics adds intergration with Google Checkout »

Advertise

WidgetBucks - Trend Watch - WidgetBucks.com

Related Resources

  • Personal Computers - PC Info and Accessories
  • SEO Copywriting - Killer-content.com provides professional copywriting, SEO copywriting, online and offline promotion services.

sponsored ads



topics

Incredible Hall of Acclaim.

subscribe


Prefer Email?
Subscribe below-

Enter your Email:


Powered by FeedBlitz What's this?

Current News

Support This Blog

My site was nominated for Best Business Blog!

Small Business Marketing - Working on small business marketing projects? Visit HP's new site for helpful information and ideas.

business social media

Use these fast growing business social media sites to promote your business, feature your products, spotlight your business leaders, create links, and drive traffic back to your company site, all for free!

BIZZlogos - Add your logo - free link to your site
BIZZphotos - Add photos of your products and people
BIZZprofiles - Submit your profile and build your online visibility
BIZZspotlight - Spotlight your business with free links
BIZZvideos - Videos about businesses, products and business people.
BIZZbites - "Digg" for Business - Submit your articles and posts

know more media network

View Network Map

Network Feed List (OPML)

Know More Media Network
Feed


we support unitus

PRWeb

Influencer



WebMetricsGuru is a member of the Know More Media network of business related blogs.

Here are some current headlines from some of our business publications:

ProductivityGoal

CallCenterScript

AdHurl

TheBizofKnowledge

LandingTheDeal

CustomersAreAlways

HealthCareVox

WebMetricsGuru

TheInsurancePolicy

MarketingBlurb